Europeans Court China’s Support to Prevent Delays to Critical Keep Climate Action on Track

COP31 climate conference in Antalya, Turkey

European governments are intensifying diplomatic efforts to persuade China to support the timely publication of the United Nations’ next major climate science assessments, amid a growing political dispute that threatens to delay crucial scientific guidance ahead of the 2028 global climate stocktake.

Senior officials from several European delegations are holding discussions with their Chinese counterparts on the sidelines of the United Nations climate conference in Antalya, Turkey, in an attempt to resolve the deadlock surrounding the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), according to five climate negotiators familiar with the discussions.

The diplomatic initiative comes as a group of countries led by India and Saudi Arabia seeks to postpone the publication of the IPCC’s seventh assessment report, while also blocking approval of the organization’s budget, creating uncertainty over its ability to continue its scientific work.

European officials consider China’s position particularly important because Beijing could help persuade the opposing countries to accept the proposed publication schedule and prevent a wider institutional crisis.

“There’s a big diplomatic move,” said Francesco Corvaro, Italy’s climate envoy. “We’re working to create pressure.”

The dispute has emerged as one of the most consequential issues surrounding the scientific foundations of international climate negotiations. The IPCC, established by the United Nations, produces comprehensive scientific assessments every five to seven years, providing governments with authoritative evaluations of climate change, its consequences and possible responses.

Its next assessment cycle is expected to produce three major reports, covering the physical science of climate change, adaptation to its impacts and measures to limit further global warming.

Scientists hope to complete the reports in 2028, allowing governments to use the findings during the second global stocktake, known as GST2, scheduled for the 2028 United Nations climate conference, COP33.

The stocktake will be a critical assessment of how far countries have progressed in implementing the 2015 Paris Agreement and whether additional measures are required to keep global warming within internationally agreed limits.

European governments and many climate-vulnerable developing countries argue that delaying the IPCC reports would deprive negotiations of the latest scientific evidence at a decisive moment.

“We have this issue with the IPCC — the alliance of Saudi Arabia and India that wants to postpone the reports,” Corvaro said. “Without the reports of the IPCC, it’s tough to have a good global stocktake. We need to know the details of how far we’re falling short if we want to respond.”

The European Union has strongly defended the proposed timetable, emphasizing that scientific assessments must be available before governments undertake the next global review.

“It is essential that the IPCC continues its work and that the seventh assessment report can be delivered in good time to inform GST2,” EU chief negotiator Diana Acconcia told reporters last week. “Europe stands on the side of science.”

However, India and Saudi Arabia argue that additional time is necessary to ensure meaningful participation by scientists and government representatives from developing countries.

They maintain that researchers and officials from poorer nations need sufficient opportunities to examine, review and approve the scientific assessments before publication.

“You have to give adequate time” to developing countries’ scientists, said an official from a developing country opposing the 2028 publication schedule. The official requested anonymity because of the sensitivity of the negotiations.

The official described the position as a matter of principle rather than an effort to obstruct the scientific process.

India and Saudi Arabia have proposed an alternative arrangement under which the first report, focusing on climate science, would be published in time for the 2028 stocktake. The other two reports, addressing adaptation and climate mitigation policies, would be postponed until 2029.

European governments and other countries opposing the delay argue that this arrangement would significantly weaken the stocktake by withholding essential information about the measures needed to address climate change.

The Marshall Islands, among the countries most vulnerable to rising sea levels and extreme weather, has also strongly defended the existing timetable.

“We have seen efforts to undermine the IPCC and to block its reports informing the next global stocktake,” President Hilda Heine said last week. “Our Pacific scientists tell us the work can and should be completed on time.”

The leaders of Norway and Brazil have similarly expressed support for the IPCC’s role in providing scientific guidance for climate negotiations.

A French official described the Indian and Saudi Arabian efforts as “absolutely unacceptable,” arguing that the dispute effectively questions the authority of climate science.

The controversy has become increasingly complicated because disagreements over the publication timetable are now intertwined with the IPCC’s financial position.

The organization is already facing significant budgetary pressure following the withdrawal of the United States, which has affected the resources available for its operations. Without an approved budget, the IPCC could struggle to organize meetings, coordinate scientific assessments and support the work of hundreds of researchers involved in preparing its reports.

For six consecutive meetings, the IPCC’s governing assembly has failed to reach agreement. Its most recent gathering in Ethiopia last month was suspended without a resolution.

Governments are scheduled to meet again on December 1, in what diplomats describe as a decisive opportunity to approve the organization’s budget for the coming year.

The deadlock has transformed what would normally be a technical discussion about scientific publication schedules and institutional financing into a major diplomatic confrontation.

India and Saudi Arabia have received support from Kenya and Russia, while China has also raised concerns about the proposed accelerated publication schedule.

Nevertheless, European governments believe Beijing has not fully aligned itself with the opposing countries and could still support a compromise.

“China is in the middle — not completely aligned with Saudi Arabia and India,” Corvaro said. “We hope it’s possible to get a common understanding with them to underline the importance of science and data.”

China’s position could therefore determine whether the negotiations move toward agreement or remain trapped in the existing deadlock.

European officials are seeking to use the Antalya climate conference, which has brought together ministers and senior representatives from across the world, to secure political support for the IPCC’s proposed timetable before the December meeting.

One European diplomat, who was not authorized to speak publicly, said the discussions could be decisive.

“We have an opportunity here to get consensus on the IPCC with ministers here,” the diplomat said. “If they manage that, I can’t see next month’s IPCC meeting fail. Otherwise, it might be doomed.”

The negotiations also carry broader political implications because the IPCC’s scientific assessments have increasingly influenced debates over fossil fuels, energy transitions and the responsibilities of major economies.

The previous global stocktake, concluded in 2023, produced a landmark agreement calling on countries to transition away from fossil fuels in energy systems. It marked the first time that such language had been included in a formal decision adopted by all governments at a United Nations climate conference.

Saudi Arabia has subsequently sought to weaken or reverse elements of that outcome, adding another layer of political sensitivity to the current disagreement.

European governments are consequently concerned that postponing the IPCC’s next reports could weaken the scientific basis for future decisions on reducing emissions and accelerating the transition toward cleaner energy.

At the same time, diplomats are cautious about formally bringing the IPCC dispute into the main political negotiations at COP, because the scientific body operates under separate United Nations procedures.

A second European diplomat said governments needed to avoid complicating the IPCC’s internal decision-making while recognizing the urgency of securing financial stability.

“We have to be careful here. We don’t want to make things more difficult for the IPCC,” the diplomat said. “But if they don’t agree on a budget in December, it will delay and disrupt work on the next reports. That’s unacceptable.”

The governments of India and Saudi Arabia did not respond to requests for comment. Meanwhile, the anonymous developing-country official said their delegation would oppose attempts to incorporate the IPCC dispute into the formal decision text of the Antalya conference.

A preliminary draft of the conference’s final decision, released Monday, indicates that governments may acknowledge the “importance of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change for the global stocktake.”

The IPCC has welcomed the diplomatic discussions taking place alongside the climate conference, saying that an early political agreement would provide much-needed certainty for scientists and the institution.

Vice Chair Diana Ürge-Vorsatz said the involvement of government representatives at the Antalya summit could help resolve the impasse.

“I think governments talking here in this space [at COP] is extremely helpful,” she said.

She warned that continued uncertainty was creating difficulties for researchers and the organization, emphasizing that a decision was needed quickly to allow the scientific assessment process to proceed.

“It’s crucial that we have a decision very soon, because it’s very difficult for the scientists involved, it’s difficult for the institution. It’s very difficult for everyone to be in this uncertainty,” Ürge-Vorsatz said.

The dispute highlights growing tensions between scientific institutions and political interests at a time when governments face mounting pressure to strengthen their climate commitments.

Acconcia said the polarization surrounding climate science reflected a wider reluctance among some countries to accept the policy implications of scientific findings.

“Why has it become polarized? Because, unfortunately, at the moment everything is polarized. And because there are some parties that are trying to undermine what science is telling us, because they don’t want to do what it takes to address climate change,” she said.

The European Union, she added, would continue pressing for an agreement during the Antalya conference.

“We will fight for this outcome to be there.”

With the December 1 IPCC meeting approaching, the diplomatic initiative to bring China closer to the European position has become increasingly important. Failure to reach agreement could threaten the organization’s budget, disrupt the preparation of its next scientific assessments and leave the 2028 global stocktake without the comprehensive scientific guidance governments say they need to evaluate their progress under the Paris Agreement.

Related Posts