UK Should Not Rush Into Second Brexit Referendum, Pro-EU Liberal Democrats Warn Amid Renewed Calls for Closer European Ties

Al Pinkerton

The United Kingdom must prioritise domestic reforms and avoid rushing into another referendum on European Union membership, the Liberal Democrats have warned, as political pressure grows for closer ties with Brussels and a possible return to the bloc.

Al Pinkerton, the Liberal Democrats’ spokesperson on Europe, said the 2016 Brexit referendum had left deep political and social divisions in Britain, warning that reopening the question of EU membership too quickly could revive tensions that took years to develop and resolve.

“There’s deep trauma associated with the 2016 vote,” Pinkerton said on Thursday when asked whether his party would accelerate its support for a referendum on rejoining the European Union.

“We rush that at our peril,” he added, stressing that any move towards closer European integration must bring the British public along rather than impose another major constitutional decision without sufficient public support.

Pinkerton was speaking ahead of Friday’s UK-EU summit in Brussels, where British and European leaders are expected to sign agreements covering food trade, carbon emissions and youth mobility. The summit comes amid renewed debate over the economic and political consequences of Brexit and Britain’s long-term relationship with the European Union.

British Prime Minister Andy Burnham has recently indicated a willingness to examine longer-term options for relations with Brussels, prompting renewed calls within the governing Labour Party for a more ambitious European policy.

Three former Labour Cabinet ministers, Rachel Reeves, David Lammy and Peter Kyle, have called in recent weeks for Britain to rejoin the European Union. Their interventions have intensified discussions about whether Brexit has weakened Britain’s economic prospects and international influence.

However, Burnham has maintained that his government will honour Labour’s 2024 general election manifesto during the current parliamentary term. The manifesto ruled out returning to the EU single market, which includes the principle of free movement, or rejoining the customs union.

The Liberal Democrats, the third-largest party in the House of Commons, support a more ambitious approach. Their proposals include rejoining the single market, establishing a bespoke customs union and negotiating broader economic growth and defence partnerships with the European Union.

Although the party ultimately supports Britain’s return to the bloc, it argues that the process should begin with gradual improvements in relations rather than an immediate push for another membership referendum.

Pinkerton said incremental agreements could demonstrate the economic advantages of closer cooperation and rebuild confidence between Britain and the EU before more substantial political decisions are considered.

He acknowledged that discussions within the Liberal Democrats about accelerating the party’s position on EU membership were continuing. However, he highlighted the existing distrust between Britain and the European Union as a significant obstacle.

According to Pinkerton, any government seeking to rejoin the bloc would face strong public expectations that the decision should be put to a referendum, given that the country originally left through a public vote in 2016.

“The public would rightly ask the very difficult questions of a political party that did seek to make that move without going back to them,” he said.

The prospect of another referendum has also revived opposition among Brexit supporters, who argue that reopening the membership debate would once again consume parliamentary time and political attention at the expense of domestic priorities.

Pinkerton acknowledged that criticism, describing it as an entirely fair argument. He said Britain had numerous internal challenges that required urgent political attention and should not be overshadowed by another prolonged debate over Europe.

It was one of the reasons, he suggested, that he would not want to initiate the referendum process immediately.

On the practical implications of rejoining the EU, Pinkerton expressed optimism that Britain could remain outside both the eurozone and the Schengen passport-free travel area. However, he cautioned that there was no guarantee Britain could secure the budget rebate negotiated by former Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher in the 1980s.

The Liberal Democrats are also seeking to distinguish their European policy from Burnham’s emerging position. Pinkerton dismissed concerns that Labour’s renewed interest in closer EU relations could politically undermine his party.

He suggested that Burnham faced considerable resistance within his own parliamentary party to moving beyond limited improvements in relations with Brussels.

“I look at the whites of the eyes of so many of his own MPs and I can see that there’s not an appetite for him to go any further than the light flirtation that he’s been engaged in over the last few weeks,” Pinkerton said.

The European debate is also unfolding against a changing political landscape across the continent. Pinkerton said he was deeply uneasy about the possibility of National Rally leader Marine Le Pen winning France’s next presidential election and expressed concern over the recent electoral performance of the far-right Alternative for Germany.

Nevertheless, he argued that the rise of nationalist and populist movements should not weaken Britain’s ambition to develop substantially closer relations with Europe.

Instead, he believes stronger economic cooperation and improved growth prospects could help address some of the conditions contributing to populist politics.

Pinkerton said the Liberal Democrats’ position was not based on an unquestioning belief that the European Union was without weaknesses.

“We’re not making our propositions through a blind adherence to the idea that Europe is entirely virtuous and has no flaws,” he said.

His comments underline the political balancing act facing Britain’s pro-European parties: rebuilding economic and diplomatic relations with the European Union while avoiding another divisive national confrontation over Brexit.

Related Posts