Foreign Affairs
India-China border dispute: Why do India-China border disputes?

India and China have border disputes due to a variety of factors, including historical grievances, territorial claims, strategic interests, and cultural and ethnic differences.

The border disputes between India and China have their roots in history. In the late 19th and early 20th century, the British Empire expanded its control over India and also established a presence in Tibet, which was then a buffer state between India and China. When the British left the region in 1947, they left behind a complicated legacy of territorial claims that have been the subject of dispute between India and China ever since.

The primary cause of the border disputes between India and China is territorial claims. China claims large parts of the Indian state of Arunachal Pradesh, which it refers to as South Tibet. India, on the other hand, claims Aksai Chin, a region that China controls at the western part of the border. The two sides also have different perceptions of the Line of Actual Control (LAC), which has led to several incidents of border skirmishes and standoffs.

India and China are rising powers with significant strategic interests in the region. China sees India as a competitor in its quest for regional dominance, while India is wary of China’s growing influence in South Asia. The disputed border provides a strategic advantage to both sides, as control over certain regions would allow them to secure their borders and project power in the region.

India and China are two vastly different countries with distinct cultural and ethnic identities. India is a predominantly Hindu country with a diverse population, while China is a predominantly Confucian country with a homogeneous population. These cultural and ethnic differences have contributed to a lack of understanding between the two countries and have made it difficult for them to resolve the border disputes.

The border disputes between India and China are also influenced by the larger international geopolitical dynamics. Both India and China have alliances and strategic partnerships with other countries that influence their foreign policy decisions. The United States, for instance, has been working to deepen its strategic partnership with India, while China has developed close ties with Pakistan.

The border disputes between India and China are complex issues that involve a variety of factors, including historical grievances, territorial claims, strategic interests, cultural and ethnic differences, and international geopolitical dynamics. Finding a peaceful and mutually acceptable solution to the border disputes will require a combination of diplomatic, economic, and military efforts from both sides.

Why is there a border dispute between India and China?

The India-China border dispute has its roots in history and is a complex issue that involves a variety of factors, including territorial claims, historical grievances, and strategic interests. The two countries share a border that stretches over 3,488 km, known as the Line of Actual Control (LAC), which has been a source of tension between the two countries for decades. Here are some of the key reasons behind the border dispute:

  • Historical legacy: The border dispute has its roots in the colonial legacy of India and China. In the late 19th and early 20th century, the British Empire expanded its control over India and also established a presence in Tibet, which was then a buffer state between India and China. When the British left the region in 1947, they left behind a complicated legacy of territorial claims that have been the subject of dispute between India and China ever since.
  • Territorial claims: The primary cause of the border dispute between India and China is territorial claims. China claims large parts of the Indian state of Arunachal Pradesh, which it refers to as South Tibet. India, on the other hand, claims Aksai Chin, a region that China controls at the western part of the border. The two sides also have different perceptions of the LAC, which has led to several incidents of border skirmishes and standoffs.
  • Strategic interests: Both India and China are rising powers with significant strategic interests in the region. China sees India as a competitor in its quest for regional dominance, while India is wary of China’s growing influence in South Asia. The disputed border provides a strategic advantage to both sides, as control over certain regions would allow them to secure their borders and project power in the region.
  • Cultural and ethnic differences: India and China are two vastly different countries with distinct cultural and ethnic identities. India is a predominantly Hindu country with a diverse population, while China is a predominantly Confucian country with a homogeneous population. These cultural and ethnic differences have contributed to a lack of understanding between the two countries and have made it difficult for them to resolve the border dispute.
  • International geopolitical dynamics: The India-China border dispute is also influenced by the larger international geopolitical dynamics. Both India and China have alliances and strategic partnerships with other countries that influence their foreign policy decisions. The United States, for instance, has been working to deepen its strategic partnership with India, while China has developed close ties with Pakistan.

The India-China border dispute has its roots in history and is a complex issue that involves a variety of factors. Territorial claims, historical grievances, and strategic interests are some of the key reasons behind the dispute. Resolving the border dispute will require a combination of diplomatic, economic, and military efforts from both sides, and it is essential to find a peaceful and mutually acceptable solution to ensure stability and security in the region.

What is the recent conflict between China and India?

The recent conflict between China and India occurred in the Galwan Valley in the disputed region of Ladakh along the Line of Actual Control (LAC) in May 2020. The incident resulted in the deaths of at least 20 Indian soldiers and an unknown number of Chinese soldiers.

The clash was the most serious between the two countries in decades and sparked a tense standoff between the two armies in the region. It is important to note that there have been several other incidents of border skirmishes and standoffs between the two countries in recent years, but the clash in the Galwan Valley was by far the most serious.

The exact cause of the clash is still not clear, and both sides have accused the other of provoking the incident. However, it is believed to have been triggered by the deployment of Chinese troops to areas that India considers its territory, which led to a confrontation between the two sides.

The clash in the Galwan Valley marked a significant escalation in the India-China border dispute, which has been simmering for decades. It also raised concerns about the growing strategic competition between the two countries and their ability to peacefully manage their differences.

Following the clash, both countries engaged in a series of diplomatic talks to ease tensions in the region. The talks resulted in a disengagement agreement in February 2021, under which both sides agreed to withdraw their troops from certain areas in the region.

However, the situation along the LAC remains tense, and there are concerns that any miscalculation or misunderstanding could lead to another escalation in the conflict. Both countries have increased their military presence in the region, and the border dispute continues to be a source of tension between the two countries.

India and China are two of the world’s most populous countries, with a combined population of more than 2.7 billion people. The two countries share a border that stretches over 3,488 kilometers and is known as the Line of
Actual Control (LAC). The border dispute between India and China has been ongoing for more than six decades and has led to several military confrontations, including the most recent one in 2020. This essay aims to explore why the situation has escalated after years and examine the historical, political, and economic factors that have contributed to the dispute.

The roots of the India-China border dispute can be traced back to the colonial era when both India and China were under British rule. In 1914, the British Empire and Tibet signed the Simla Accord, which defined the McMahon Line, a boundary between Tibet and British India. However, China, which claimed sovereignty over Tibet, refused to recognize the McMahon Line and instead proposed the Johnson Line, which included parts of the Indian state of Arunachal Pradesh in China’s territory. The dispute remained unresolved until India became independent in 1947 and China’s Communist Party took control of the country in 1949.

In 1950, China occupied Tibet and announced that the McMahon Line was illegal. This move was followed by a series of incursions by the Chinese troops into Indian territory, culminating in the 1962 Sino-Indian War, which lasted for a month and resulted in India’s defeat. In the aftermath of the war, India and China signed the 1962 Sino-Indian Agreement, which established a de facto border between the two countries, known as the Line of Actual Control (LAC).

Political Factors

The border dispute between India and China is not just a territorial dispute, but also a geopolitical one. Both countries are major powers in Asia and have competing interests in the region. India is a democracy and has strong ties with the United States, Japan, and Australia, which are seen as countering China’s influence in the region. China, on the other hand, is a one-party state and has expanded its economic and military influence in the region through its Belt and Road Initiative and its military presence in the South China Sea.

In recent years, China has become increasingly assertive in its territorial claims, which has led to tensions with its neighbours, including India. The Doklam standoff in 2017, where Chinese troops tried to construct a road in a disputed area between China and Bhutan, brought the two countries to the brink of war. The situation was defused after 73 days of stand-off, but it was a clear indication of China’s growing assertiveness in the region.

India’s growing ties with the US have also contributed to the tensions between India and China. In 2017, India and the US signed the Logistics Exchange Memorandum of Agreement (LEMOA), which allows the two countries to share military logistics facilities. This move was seen as a strategic shift by India towards the US, and China viewed it as a challenge to its regional dominance.

Economic Factors

The economic relationship between India and China has been growing rapidly over the past two decades. China is India’s largest trading partner, with trade between the two countries reaching $85.5 billion in 2020. However, the trade relationship is heavily skewed in China’s favour, with India importing more than it exports to China.

India has been trying to reduce its dependence on China and has taken several measures to curb Chinese imports, including banning several Chinese apps and restricting imports of Chinese goods. This move has irked China, which sees India’s efforts as an attempt to contain its economic rise.

India and China, as well as their respective economies. In 2020, India’s GDP contracted by 7.7%, while China’s economy grew by 2.3%. The pandemic also highlighted India’s dependence on China for essential medical supplies, which led to India’s push for self-reliance and a shift towards domestic manufacturing.

China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) has also been a point of contention between India and China. The BRI is a massive infrastructure development project aimed at connecting Asia, Africa, and Europe through a network of ports, railways, and highways. India has been critical of the BRI, as it includes the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor, which passes through Pakistan-administered Kashmir, a territory that India claims as its own.

China’s growing economic influence in South Asia and its push for the BRI have also led to concerns among India’s smaller neighbours, such as Sri Lanka and Nepal, who fear that they may become too dependent on China. India has been trying to counter China’s influence in the region through its development initiatives, such as the International North-South Transport Corridor and the Asia-Africa Growth Corridor.

India-China border dispute

The most escalation in the border dispute between India and China occurred in May 2020, when Chinese troops began building infrastructure on Indian territory in the Galwan Valley. The move led to a clash between the two sides, resulting in the deaths of 20 Indian soldiers and an unknown number of Chinese soldiers. The incident was the deadliest clash between the two countries since 1967 and led to a heightened state of tension along the LAC.

In June 2020, the two countries engaged in talks to de-escalate the situation, but the talks were inconclusive. In September 2020, the two sides agreed to a five-point consensus to de-escalate tensions, including the disengagement of troops and a reduction in military activities along the LAC. However, progress has been slow, and tensions continue to simmer between the two countries.

The India-China border dispute is a complex issue that has historical, political, and economic roots. The dispute is not just a territorial one but also a geopolitical one, with both countries vying for influence in the region. China’s growing assertiveness and India’s shift towards the US have contributed to the tensions between the two countries.

The economic relationship between India and China has been growing rapidly over the past two decades, but it is heavily skewed in China’s favour. India’s efforts to reduce its dependence on China and its push for self-reliance have irked China, which sees India’s efforts as an attempt to contain its economic rise.

Recent developments, such as the Galwan Valley clash and the slow progress in talks to de-escalate tensions, have highlighted the fragile nature of the India-China relationship. It remains to be seen how the situation will evolve in the coming years and whether the two countries will be able to find a lasting solution to the border dispute.

The military has played a significant role in the India-China border dispute. The disputed border between the two countries is heavily militarized, with both sides deploying large numbers of troops, tanks, and artillery along the Line of Actual Control (LAC). The military buildup on both sides has been a major factor contributing to the tensions between the two countries.

India has a large and well-equipped military, with over 1.4 million active-duty personnel. The Indian Army is one of the largest standing armies in the world and has a significant presence along the LAC. India has been investing heavily in modernizing its military capabilities in recent years, with a particular focus on enhancing its air and naval capabilities.

China, on the other hand, has the largest standing army in the world, with over 2 million active-duty personnel. China has also been investing heavily in modernizing its military capabilities, with a particular focus on developing advanced technologies such as artificial intelligence, hypersonic weapons, and quantum computing.

The military buildup on both sides has led to several incidents of border skirmishes and standoffs. The most recent clash between Indian and Chinese troops occurred in May 2020, resulting in the deaths of 20 Indian soldiers and an unknown number of Chinese soldiers. The incident led to a heightened state of tension along the LAC and sparked protests in India calling for a boycott of Chinese goods.

The military buildup on both sides has also had a significant impact on the local populations living along the border. The presence of large numbers of troops has led to restrictions on the movement of civilians, and the military buildup has harmed the environment.

In addition to the military buildup, both India and China have been engaged in the modernization and expansion of their nuclear arsenals. Both countries possess nuclear weapons, and the nuclear factor adds a layer of complexity to the India-China relationship.

The military has also played a role in attempts to de-escalate tensions between India and China. In June 2020, the two countries engaged in talks to de-escalate the situation, and military commanders from both sides held several rounds of talks. However, progress has been slow, and tensions continue to simmer between the two countries.

The military has been a significant factor in the India-China border dispute, with both sides deploying large numbers of troops, tanks, and artillery along the LAC. The military buildup on both sides has led to several incidents of border skirmishes and standoffs, and the presence of large numbers of troops has harmed the local populations living along the border.

The military has also played a role in attempts to de-escalate tensions between India and China, with military commanders from both sides engaging in talks. However, progress has been slow, and tensions continue to simmer between the two countries.

It remains to be seen how the situation will evolve in the coming years, but the military will continue to play a significant role in the India-China border dispute. A peaceful resolution to the dispute will require a combination of diplomatic, economic, and military efforts from both sides.

Economic FactorsIndia ChinaIndia-China borderIndia-China Border conflictIndia-China border disputeIndia-China border dispute: Why do India-China border disputes?India-China conflictIndia-China militaryIndia-China TiesPolitical FactorsWhat is the recent conflict between China and India?Why do India-China border disputes?Why is there a border dispute between India and China?

© 2024 ASIA MEDIA RESEARCH CENTER PVT. LTD. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.