Japan’s Ruling Coalition Poised to Lose Parliamentary Majority, Setting Stage for Uncertain Political Future

Japan general election

Japan’s ruling coalition, led by the Liberal Democratic Party (LDP) and its junior partner Komeito, is on the brink of losing its long-held parliamentary majority, as exit polls from Sunday’s general election indicate. The outcome threatens to upend Japan’s political stability as the world’s fourth-largest economy grapples with inflation, a complex geopolitical landscape, and crucial economic reforms.

Exit polls conducted by NHK, Japan’s national broadcaster, suggest that the LDP and Komeito together may secure between 174 and 254 seats out of the 465 seats in Japan’s House of Representatives. This result falls well short of the 233 seats required for a majority. Meanwhile, the main opposition, the Constitutional Democratic Party of Japan (CDPJ), is projected to win between 128 and 191 seats, potentially securing a strong bargaining position in what could be a coalition-led government.

Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba, who has only recently ascended to the LDP leadership, acknowledged the gravity of the results. “We are receiving severe judgment,” he remarked to NHK, reflecting voter discontent with his administration. The anticipated shift in parliamentary dynamics marks a significant moment in Japanese politics, with voters appearing to question the dominance of the LDP, which has ruled Japan almost continuously since World War II.

The election follows a series of political and economic controversies that have eroded public trust in the LDP. Public frustration has mounted over recent funding scandals within the party and persistent inflation that has strained household budgets. A Nippon TV poll showed the ruling coalition trailing with 198 seats compared to 157 for the CDPJ, reinforcing the notion that voters are dissatisfied with the current leadership’s handling of critical issues.

Shinjiro Koizumi, the LDP’s chief of election strategy, commented on the defeat, attributing it to unresolved political scandals. “These results reflect an unsparing verdict on the LDP… stemming from how we have not been able to settle the political money issue from two winters ago,” he told NHK. Prime Minister Ishiba had hoped to reestablish party legitimacy through a snap election soon after his appointment, but the move appears to have backfired amid public dissatisfaction.

Three main issues drove the vote, with significant implications for Japan’s future government:

  • Economic Hardship: The cost-of-living crisis has affected a wide swath of Japanese society. Wages have struggled to keep pace with inflation, and consumer prices have risen sharply in recent months. Many voters blame the LDP for failing to adequately address these economic challenges.
  • Funding Scandals: Unresolved scandals involving unreported donations to LDP lawmakers have damaged the party’s image. Although the party sought to address these issues, they remain a major point of contention, influencing voter sentiment.
  • Political Stability and Regional Security: The broader security landscape in East Asia has become increasingly fraught, particularly as Japan confronts challenges from neighboring North Korea and a rising China. The perceived need for a strong and stable government to manage these complex international dynamics loomed large over the election.

The anticipated shortfall in parliamentary seats suggests that Japan may enter an era of coalition politics, with parties potentially locked in challenging negotiations to form a workable government. Analysts warn that without a clear majority, the ruling coalition could struggle to push through essential reforms, including controversial policies on defense and economic restructuring.

Election officers prepare to count ballots for the general election at a ballot counting centre in Tokyo, Japan
Election officers prepare to count ballots for the general election at a ballot counting centre in Tokyo, Japan on Oct 27, 2024. Reuters.

Masafumi Fujihara, an associate professor of politics at Yamanashi University, underscored the implications for Japan’s policy agenda. “With a more fluid political landscape, pushing through economic policies, such as raising taxes to fund defense spending, will become much harder,” he noted. “Without a strong government, it will be more difficult for the Bank of Japan (BOJ) to raise rates and manage the weak yen.”

Should the LDP and Komeito fall short of the majority threshold, attention will turn to Japan’s smaller parties, such as the Democratic Party for the People (DPP) and the Japan Innovation Party. Both parties are projected to secure a small but potentially decisive number of seats—20 to 33 for the DPP and 28 to 45 for the Innovation Party, according to NHK’s exit polls.

However, cooperation with these parties is far from guaranteed. The DPP and Innovation Party have staked out positions that diverge significantly from the LDP.

  • Economic Policy: The DPP has campaigned on a platform to cut Japan’s sales tax in half, bringing it down from 10% until real wages recover. This proposal contrasts sharply with the LDP’s fiscally conservative stance.
  • Political Reform: The Innovation Party has pledged tougher rules around political donations in an effort to clean up Japanese politics. Its leader, Nobuyuki Baba, has expressed dissatisfaction with the status quo, stating that a change in leadership could help restore public trust.

With the ruling coalition poised to lose its majority, the possibility of prolonged coalition negotiations could lead to market uncertainty. The Nikkei index, Japan’s primary stock market benchmark, dropped by 2.7% last week in anticipation of a challenging election outcome for the LDP. Investors remain concerned about Japan’s direction under a divided government, particularly as it pertains to interest rates and the yen’s valuation.

The BOJ, which has maintained near-zero interest rates as part of its expansive monetary policy, may face significant challenges should political gridlock ensue. A weaker coalition might hinder the central bank’s efforts to gradually tighten monetary policy and rein in inflation without triggering a recession. Moreover, should the DPP gain influence within the coalition, Japan’s economic policy direction could shift markedly toward more aggressive fiscal stimulus measures.

The election outcome is also set to impact Japan’s regional security posture, especially as tensions rise in East Asia. Japan’s defense budget has been gradually increasing, a trend supported by the LDP and Komeito. However, if the LDP fails to form a strong coalition, implementing further defense spending increases could prove difficult, potentially weakening Japan’s position amid an unpredictable regional security environment.

The looming U.S. election, scheduled just nine days after Japan’s, adds another layer of complexity. Japan’s foreign policy strategy is closely tied to its alliance with the United States. Any shifts in Washington’s approach to East Asia, particularly regarding China and North Korea, could further strain Japan’s policymaking process should the government face significant domestic instability.

For many voters, economic and political stability were key concerns. Keisuke Yoshitomi, a 39-year-old office worker in Tokyo, shared his rationale for supporting the DPP. “The DPP is focused on ultimately making the country better and ensuring financial resources are allocated more appropriately,” he said after casting his vote.

In contrast, younger voters in urban areas seemed more inclined toward the Innovation Party, with many seeing its anti-corruption platform as a necessary intervention for Japanese politics. “We need a fresh start, and that means leaders who aren’t tainted by scandal,” said university student Aya Nakamura, aged 22, who cast her ballot in Osaka.

Political analysts suggest that the weeks following the election will be crucial in determining Japan’s governance path. 

  • LDP-Komeito Retain Power with Minor Support: If the ruling coalition can secure enough seats through partnerships with minor parties, it may still lead but will likely encounter frequent policy roadblocks.
  • Broad-Based Coalition with Opposition Inclusion: A coalition that includes the DPP or Innovation Party would require significant compromises on both sides, especially on economic and fiscal policy.
  • Minority Government Scenario: Should no coalition achieve a workable majority, Japan could enter a period of minority rule, where policy deadlock could stymie essential reforms and exacerbate market instability.

Related Posts