On the busy High Street of Northcote, a traditionally progressive neighbourhood in Melbourne’s inner north, voters are increasingly questioning the direction of Victorian politics. But the concerns driving dissatisfaction with the state’s Labor government extend beyond crime, infrastructure controversies and allegations of corruption. For many left-leaning voters, the central issues are federal Labor’s response to the Gaza conflict, the humanitarian consequences of Israel’s military campaign and growing anxiety over the rise of far-right politics.
As Victoria prepares for its November 28 election, the contest is exposing a significant challenge for the Labor Party: while conservative parties are gaining ground across regional cities and suburban communities, Labor is also facing an increasingly competitive challenge from the Greens in its traditional inner-city strongholds.
After 12 years in government, Labor, now led by Ben Carroll, is confronting widespread electoral dissatisfaction. The Coalition, under Liberal leader Jess Wilson, appears increasingly well positioned to capitalise on the discontent and potentially return to government, possibly with support from One Nation.
However, Melbourne’s progressive inner suburbs are witnessing a different political contest. Rather than simply choosing between Labor and the Coalition, voters are increasingly weighing whether the Greens offer a stronger alternative on climate policy, housing affordability, social welfare, humanitarian issues and opposition to the far right.
The changing political mood is reflected in recent polling. A DemosAU/PremierNational survey conducted between October 30 and November 5, involving 1,562 voters, found Labor’s primary vote had fallen seven percentage points to 18 per cent, while the Greens had gained three points to reach 17 per cent.
The figures suggest the Greens are approaching a potentially historic breakthrough, threatening Labor’s longstanding dominance of the progressive vote in Victoria.
The same survey placed the Liberal-National Coalition ahead with 33 per cent of the primary vote and 56 per cent on a two-party-preferred basis. Nevertheless, the Greens interpreted the figures as evidence of a broader political shift.
Federal Greens leader David Shoebridge described the emerging trend on social media platform X as a potential Green wave, arguing that community-driven political movements could challenge established political parties and their financial influence.
“A massive community-powered Green wave is set to overtake Labor in the latest Victorian election polls,” Shoebridge wrote, claiming that public mobilisation could defeat what he described as the influence of money and political greed.
The electoral arithmetic in Melbourne’s inner north makes the possibility of a Greens breakthrough particularly significant.
At the 2022 Victorian election, the Greens secured four lower-house seats, winning Brunswick, Melbourne, Prahran and Richmond. Prahran was subsequently lost to the Liberals in a by-election following the resignation of its former representative, Sam Hibbins.
Several other inner-northern electorates were narrowly decided, with Labor managing to hold off the Greens by small margins. In Northcote, the difference was just 0.2 percentage points, while Labor retained Pascoe Vale and Preston by approximately two percentage points.
Those results demonstrated how vulnerable Labor’s traditional electoral base had become, particularly among younger voters, renters, environmental campaigners and progressive communities.
Conversations with more than a dozen voters along Northcote’s High Street reveal that the political debate is increasingly shaped by issues extending beyond conventional state-election concerns.
Affordable housing, the cost of living, welfare support, climate action, refugee rights, Palestine and the threat posed by far-right political movements repeatedly emerged as major considerations.
For some voters, the Gaza conflict has become an important test of political credibility, with the Greens benefiting from their more forceful criticism of Israel’s military operations and their use of the term genocide to describe the campaign.
Ash, who declined to provide her family name, identified Palestine, the cost of living, refugee rights and environmental protection as her principal concerns. She said she was likely to vote for the Greens, expressing dissatisfaction with the major parties’ approach to issues she considers fundamental.
She argued that Labor and the Coalition often appear too similar on important questions, making it difficult for voters seeking a distinctly progressive political alternative.
Eamonn Hayes, another Northcote resident, highlighted public transport and crime policy as important issues. He said he would like to see free public transport and criticised Labor’s recent announcements promising a tougher approach to crime and policing.
Hayes questioned whether the government’s emphasis on youth crime reflected the actual priorities of the community, describing the political focus as a distraction from more pressing social challenges.
He also expressed dissatisfaction with federal Labor’s foreign policy, particularly its position on the Gaza conflict, accusing the government of following Washington’s lead rather than pursuing an independent humanitarian position.
The issue is also influencing voters who have traditionally supported Labor.
Cath Wangeman, from neighbouring Thornbury, described herself as a gay woman and a left-leaning voter who prioritises humanitarian principles when deciding which political party to support.
Although she has consistently voted Labor in the past, she said she remained undecided about the November election.
Wangeman criticised political candidates for becoming highly visible during election campaigns while appearing less engaged with communities between elections.
For her, the choice is fundamentally connected to compassion, social justice and the treatment of vulnerable communities.
She argued that political parties should be judged by their actions rather than campaign promises, suggesting that humanitarian values should remain central to political decision-making.
Not all progressive voters, however, are convinced that the Greens represent a practical alternative to Labor.
Mel, a doctor working in Victoria’s public health system, said healthcare funding, the continuation of major infrastructure projects and political accountability were among her leading concerns.
She also raised questions about Labor’s relationship with trade unions and allegations of corruption associated with major infrastructure developments.
Although generally a Labor supporter, Mel acknowledged that the Greens had developed attractive policies on issues such as improved school funding. However, she questioned whether some of their proposals were realistic, arguing that opposition parties could sometimes promise solutions without having to demonstrate how they would work in government.
Alistair, another Northcote resident, similarly expressed support for both Labor and the Greens but emphasised the need for practical climate policies.
He said minority parties could find it easier to promise ambitious reforms because they were not responsible for implementing them.
Alistair also expressed reservations about Ben Carroll’s leadership, saying he did not feel personally connected to the Labor leader and believed the government was struggling to overcome the political legacy of corruption allegations surrounding its major infrastructure programme.
The debate is not confined to Melbourne’s inner north. In Niddrie, Carroll’s own electorate in Melbourne’s north-west, progressive voters are confronting similar questions about Labor’s political direction and the rise of conservative populism.
Daniella, a Labor voter in her twenties or thirties, said she was increasingly concerned about the growth of far-right politics in Australia, particularly the influence of One Nation.
She accused the party of blaming immigrants for economic and social problems without presenting meaningful policy solutions.
Daniella also criticised Liberal leader Jess Wilson’s decision to consider directing preferences towards One Nation, arguing that such an approach raised serious questions about the Coalition’s political priorities.
Her voting intentions illustrate the fragmentation of the progressive electorate. She said she planned to place the Victorian Socialists first, the Greens second and Labor third.
Her decision was influenced significantly by Palestine and what she described as a lack of honesty and transparency in the federal government’s position on Gaza.
Sonya, another Niddrie resident who leans towards Labor and the Greens, also identified the cost of living, low wages and housing affordability as major issues.
She rejected One Nation but expressed disappointment with Prime Minister Anthony Albanese and Foreign Minister Penny Wong over their handling of the Gaza conflict.
The views underline how international developments, particularly the war in Gaza, have become intertwined with domestic electoral calculations in Australia.
While foreign policy traditionally plays a secondary role in state elections, the issue has become a significant source of dissatisfaction among sections of Victoria’s progressive electorate. The Greens have attempted to translate that frustration into electoral support by positioning themselves as a more outspoken alternative on Palestinian rights and humanitarian concerns.
Statewide polling, meanwhile, suggests Labor’s difficulties extend well beyond its traditional inner-city battlegrounds.
Across Victoria, the Coalition is averaging approximately 31 per cent of the primary vote, placing it on course to challenge for majority government. One Nation is polling around 22 per cent, narrowly ahead of Labor at 21.8 per cent, while the Greens are recording approximately 14.5 per cent.
The figures indicate a fragmented political landscape in which Labor is being squeezed from both sides: by conservative parties gaining support among voters dissatisfied with the government and by the Greens competing for progressive voters in metropolitan Melbourne.
However, the outcome in individual inner-city electorates will depend heavily on preference arrangements.
Labor and the Greens have traditionally benefited from voters directing preferences towards the other progressive party ahead of the Coalition and One Nation. Approximately 85 to 90 per cent of their respective voters typically favour the other party over conservative alternatives.
But disagreements over preference strategies could influence several closely contested seats.
Labor’s decision to run an open preference ticket in Prahran is expected to complicate the Greens’ attempt to recapture the electorate. Meanwhile, the Liberals’ decision to preference Labor ahead of the Greens in Northcote, Brunswick and Richmond could prove decisive in marginal contests.
The election therefore represents more than a referendum on 12 years of Labor government. It will test whether the Coalition can convert dissatisfaction into a governing majority, whether One Nation can establish itself as a major political force and whether the Greens can turn progressive frustration into lasting electoral gains.
For Labor, the challenge is particularly serious. Its traditional supporters are not necessarily moving towards the conservative opposition. In many inner-city communities, they are questioning whether the party still represents their political values.
The November 28 election will offer an important indication of whether that dissatisfaction is temporary or marks a deeper transformation of Victoria’s political landscape.
For the Greens, the opportunity is substantial but not without risks. Their ability to challenge Labor will depend on whether voters see their policies as credible governing alternatives rather than simply expressions of protest.
For the Coalition, the central test will be whether Jess Wilson can unite conservative voters and capitalise on the growing strength of One Nation without alienating moderate communities.
Ultimately, Victoria’s election could provide an early indication of how Australia’s progressive political landscape may evolve ahead of the 2028 federal election, particularly as questions of economic insecurity, climate change, immigration, humanitarian responsibility and the rise of the far right increasingly shape voter behaviour.