US President Donald Trump’s personal rapport with Chinese President Xi Jinping is facing a difficult test as the two leaders prepare to meet in Shenzhen, with growing pressure from Congress over an alleged Chinese intelligence operation involving Nvidia and Beijing’s failure to fulfil key trade commitments.
The meeting, scheduled for Thursday on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) leaders’ gathering, will be the third of four planned encounters between Trump and Xi in 2026. However, expectations remain relatively modest, with their previous two meetings producing considerable diplomatic spectacle but few substantial agreements.
Trump has repeatedly portrayed his relationship with Xi in exceptionally positive terms, describing it as a “truly great friendship” and calling the Chinese president a “great leader.” His approach has centred on maintaining personal engagement with Beijing while preventing economic and strategic competition from escalating into a broader confrontation.
But the latest developments in Washington are making that approach increasingly difficult to sustain.
The Nvidia controversy, mounting congressional demands for tighter restrictions on technology exports and China’s failure to deliver promised purchases of American goods threaten to overshadow the carefully managed diplomatic atmosphere surrounding the Shenzhen summit.
“Trump wants the pomp of a presidential welcome and a chance to prove his rapport with Xi can keep the rivalry in check,” said Craig Singleton, a former national security official who served under Democratic and Republican administrations.
Trump sees considerable value in maintaining what Singleton described as a “managed stalemate” between the world’s two largest economies.
However, the political environment surrounding the meeting has changed considerably, with lawmakers increasingly questioning whether Trump’s personal diplomacy is producing meaningful results.
The controversy surrounding Nvidia has emerged as an unexpected complication ahead of the summit.
US officials have been examining the relationship between former Nvidia chief executive Jensen Huang and an alleged Chinese intelligence operative, an issue that has raised concerns about potential intelligence gathering, technology security and Beijing’s access to sensitive American semiconductor capabilities.
Despite the seriousness of the allegations, the Trump administration appears reluctant to make the controversy a central issue during the meeting with Xi.
A senior administration official told reporters during a briefing ahead of the summit that Trump was unlikely to raise what the official called the “Alice Huang issue.”
“I don’t expect the president to raise it,” the official said.
The White House did not respond to follow-up questions.
Nevertheless, the controversy is expected to influence the political atmosphere surrounding the negotiations, even if semiconductors and intelligence activities are not formally included on the leaders’ agenda.
Ker Gibbs, a former president of the American Chamber of Commerce in Shanghai who maintains regular contact with Chinese officials, said the scandal would remain an important consideration during the discussions.
“This scandal will be in the room even if semiconductors aren’t discussed,” Gibbs said.
He warned that any decision by Washington to relax restrictions on advanced technology exports to China could become politically damaging, particularly as Democrats prepare to take control of Congress in January and promise investigations into the administration’s China policy.
“Any concession on technology exports would look like a gift to Beijing at the worst possible moment,” he said.
The controversy has also intensified an existing debate in Washington over whether the United States should maintain or further tighten restrictions on China’s access to advanced American technology.
Several prominent lawmakers from both political parties are pressing congressional leaders to take a tougher approach towards Beijing following the Nvidia revelations.
Representative John Moolenaar, a Republican from Michigan and chairman of the House Select Committee on the Chinese Communist Party, and Senator Elizabeth Warren, a Democrat from Massachusetts, are urging Republican congressional leaders to advance three long-delayed bills designed to strengthen restrictions on technology exports to China.
Representative Michael McCaul, a Republican from Texas, has separately called for an immediate suspension of all advanced semiconductor exports to China until the allegations surrounding the Nvidia controversy are fully investigated.
In a statement posted on X, McCaul argued that the United States should halt such exports until authorities establish the full circumstances of the incident.
Senator Tim Scott, chairman of the Senate Banking Committee and a Republican from South Carolina, is also preparing to summon Huang and Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick to Capitol Hill next month.
The proposed hearings are expected to examine the alleged intelligence connection, the implications for American national security and the effectiveness of existing export-control mechanisms.
These developments expose a growing gap between Trump’s diplomatic approach and the increasingly hard-line position adopted by lawmakers in Washington.
Gibbs said the president’s friendly public relationship with Xi could become politically uncomfortable in the aftermath of the controversy.
“The bromance will look bad just days after a spy scandal,” he said. “Expect fewer smiles for the cameras and more pressure to show results.”
Beijing, meanwhile, has rejected the criticism from American lawmakers.
Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesperson Mao Ning dismissed the concerns as “a pretext for imposing technology restrictions,” arguing that Washington was using the controversy to justify further restrictions on China’s technological development.
While the Nvidia controversy may remain outside the formal agenda, the Trump administration intends to focus on China’s implementation of trade commitments made during previous negotiations.
American officials are particularly concerned about Beijing’s failure to deliver on promises involving Boeing aircraft purchases, agricultural imports and the removal of restrictions on critical mineral exports.
A second senior administration official said the Shenzhen meeting would effectively serve as a review of China’s compliance with commitments made during earlier discussions.
The official described the meeting as “a stock taking” of Beijing’s performance.
Rare earth minerals are expected to be among Trump’s principal concerns.
China occupies a dominant position in the global rare earth supply chain, giving Beijing significant influence over industries ranging from electric vehicles and renewable energy to advanced electronics, defence equipment and military systems.
Washington has become increasingly concerned about the reliability of Chinese supplies, particularly after Beijing introduced export restrictions that disrupted access to several critical materials.
The administration believes China is not delivering rare earth materials to American companies at the agreed pace and volume.
“Beijing is not supplying rare earths at the pace and at the level that we would like to be receiving them,” the senior official said.
“We really want to focus minds among our counterparts in China on compliance with this, and I expect the president will raise it with President Xi.”
The concerns have also been communicated through diplomatic and economic channels.
US Trade Representative Jamieson Greer earlier this month urged China to take “concrete actions” to fulfil its commitments.
Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent also raised the issue during a telephone conversation with Chinese Vice Premier He Lifeng, telling him that Washington expected Beijing to “fully and immediately” honour the agreements.
However, Chinese officials have shown little indication that they are prepared to accelerate implementation without additional concessions from Washington.
The disagreement extends beyond critical minerals.
Trump has repeatedly highlighted China’s commitments to purchase American agricultural products and Boeing aircraft as evidence that his negotiations with Xi are producing economic benefits for the United States.
But Beijing has yet to deliver several of the purchases Washington expected.
A Chinese Commerce Ministry spokesperson said earlier this month that the promised agricultural purchases would not proceed until the two countries finalised an agreement to reduce tariffs on approximately $30 billion worth of imports classified as nonsensitive goods.
Neither government has announced a timetable for completing that arrangement.
The disagreement illustrates the difficulty of translating political commitments made during high-level meetings into concrete commercial transactions.
For Washington, Chinese purchases of American agricultural products and aircraft would provide visible evidence that Trump’s negotiations are delivering economic benefits.
For Beijing, however, the commitments appear linked to broader negotiations over tariffs and market access.
The result is an increasingly complicated trade relationship in which both sides are seeking concessions before fulfilling their own obligations.
The current difficulties come despite months of diplomatic efforts by Trump to establish a closer working relationship with Xi.
His administration has pursued a series of gestures intended to reduce tensions and encourage Beijing to cooperate on trade and strategic issues.
These efforts included delaying a $14 billion arms sale to Taiwan in May, a move that departed from longstanding US policy towards the island.
Xi also received an elaborate state visit to Washington in September, reflecting Trump’s emphasis on personal diplomacy and high-level engagement.
However, the concessions have produced limited tangible progress.
The most significant outcome has been an extension until January of an agreement maintaining tariffs at double-digit levels and the continuation of a broader understanding that lifted China’s restrictions on rare earth exports imposed the previous year.
The two sides also made a general commitment to establish dialogue on artificial intelligence, but the arrangement has yet to produce a substantial framework for cooperation.
For critics of Trump’s strategy, the gap between diplomatic gestures and concrete outcomes is becoming increasingly difficult to ignore.
Even if Trump adopts a tougher position during the Shenzhen meeting, however, Washington may have limited leverage to force Beijing to comply.
Emily Kilcrease, a former deputy assistant US trade representative who served during Trump’s first administration and under former President Joe Biden, said the fundamental problem was the lack of effective negotiating pressure.
“The US just doesn’t have the leverage to force China to comply right now,” Kilcrease said.
“They can have all the summits they want, but until they figure out the leverage piece, that fundamental challenge doesn’t go anywhere.”
Her assessment highlights a central weakness in the administration’s approach: personal relationships and diplomatic engagement cannot necessarily overcome the structural economic and strategic advantages Beijing possesses.
Both governments have an immediate incentive to prevent the Shenzhen meeting from producing another deterioration in relations.
The existing US-China trade truce is due to expire on January 10, creating pressure for the two sides to negotiate an extension.
The arrangement has kept tariffs at double-digit levels and helped restore the flow of rare earth exports after Beijing imposed restrictions last year.
Allowing the agreement to collapse could trigger another round of economic retaliation, disrupt international supply chains and increase uncertainty for businesses operating in both countries.
However, Beijing may be reluctant to commit to a longer-term agreement with Trump, particularly as American domestic politics approach another major transition.
The Chinese leadership is aware that the political balance in Washington could change and that commitments made by the current administration may not necessarily survive a future Democratic presidency.
Mark Lambert, a former deputy assistant secretary of State for China and Taiwan under Biden, said Xi would take the American political calendar into account when evaluating the prospects for a lasting agreement.
“China’s leadership can read a calendar just like anyone else can,” Lambert said.
He argued that Xi understands the difficulty of negotiating a bilateral agreement with Washington and may question whether any arrangement reached with Trump would remain in place under a Democratic administration after the 2028 presidential election.
That uncertainty could make Beijing more cautious about accepting long-term commitments.
For Trump, the Shenzhen summit therefore presents competing priorities: maintaining the appearance of a successful personal relationship with Xi, securing immediate economic concessions and responding to growing domestic pressure over national security.
The Nvidia controversy has added another layer of complexity to an already difficult relationship.
Although the two leaders may avoid a public confrontation over the allegations, the political consequences in Washington could make it harder for Trump to offer further concessions on technology and trade.