Foreign Affairs
US-China Geopolitical Battle Impacts Micronesia’s Future: A Delicate Balancing Act

China and the Federated States of Micronesia are strengthening their bilateral relations in the Pacific Ocean, a strategic partnership that could have far-reaching implications for the entire region and the global balance of power. The relationship, rooted in the 1980s, when Micronesia gained independence, has been cordial but limited in scope.

However, in the last decade, both nations have made significant efforts to deepen their engagement, focusing on economic cooperation, infrastructure development, and addressing climate change in the Pacific. This growing China-Micronesia partnership is emblematic of China’s increasing engagement in the Pacific region, but it also poses challenges in terms of sovereignty and geopolitical balance.

To ensure transparency in agreements, prioritize environmentally sustainable practices, and continue collaboration on global issues, both nations must ensure transparency in their agreements. Micronesia should also explore ways to maintain its relationships with China and the United States without compromising its sovereignty or regional stability. The world will closely monitor these complexities as China and Micronesia navigate these complexities and build a partnership that benefits not only their nations but the entire Pacific region.

The Pacific Ocean is facing a geopolitical battle between the United States and China. The race for influence and strategic positioning intensifies, leaving Micronesia caught in the crossfire of great power competition. The fate of Micronesia is in the balance, as the choices made by its governments will have profound consequences for the Pacific and beyond. The delicate dance between economic diplomacy and military presence will continue, leaving Micronesia’s path uncertain in this era of great power rivalry.

A Chinese man living on Pohnpei island in Micronesia is involved in a road upgrade project funded by China. The project was completed in the second half of 2021 and plants are growing from the construction vehicles parked at the site. George has a strong relationship with the US and has contributed to the development of Micronesia, a North Pacific nation with close ties to the US. Micronesia and its neighbours, Palau and the Marshall Islands, have vast exclusive economic zones and strategically strategic seas near East Asia, potentially triggering China-U.S. competition. Under compacts of free association, these nations could receive over $7 billion in financial and economic assistance, subject to Congressional approval.

Micronesia’s president, David Panuelo, believes that China will be doing their best to achieve more influence in the Pacific region. Critics like Panuelo warn against allowing the relationship with the authoritarian Communist Party-ruled state to include security. The Philippines’ foreign minister, Panuelo Panuelo, has expressed concerns about China’s development projects in the Pacific region and criticized China’s choice of ambassador, Wu Wei, for his security background.

China’s Belt and Road Initiative, a decade-old plan to build infrastructure for trade, economic, and security, has been a significant part of its aid work in Micronesia and now serves as the primary method for organizing relations with the region’s states. China’s state media has sought to enlist Pacific Island media in its Belt and Road News Network, which was established to publish positive stories about Chinese infrastructure projects. However, critics argue that criticism of China’s aid projects could be used against him during campaigning for elections.

In conclusion, the Philippines faces challenges in navigating China’s development projects in the Pacific region, with concerns over transparency, unexplained visits to exclusive economic zones, and potential influence from the Chinese embassy. China’s influence in the Pacific region is extensive, but it has limitations, as seen in Papua New Guinea and Pohnpei. Construction on Fiji’s tallest building, WG Friendship Plaza, has been halted due to safety and legal controversies, while the road in Pohnpei has already shrunk in places. The state government building in Pohnpei, completed by China in 2010, is known for its use of unsuited materials and a long broken-down elevator.

The Solomon Islands, which transitioned to Beijing diplomatic recognition in 2019, has seen a golden age in relations with China. Prime Minister Manasseh Sogavare has leveraged the China-U.S. rivalry to boost development in the country, which faces challenges like job shortages, infrastructure, and healthcare. China has funded Honiara’s Pacific Games, attracting other donor nations to build sports facilities and upgrade the airport and roads.

Micronesia and Palau’s agreement to increase financial assistance from the United States under their compact of free association doesn’t mean China’s influence campaign is failing. John T. Hennessey-Niland, U.S. ambassador to Palau from 2020 to late 2022, said that there is room for cooperation and competition, but also potential for confrontation in places like the South China Sea and the Pacific. The US has increased its embassies in the Solomon Islands and Tonga and plans a mission in Vanuatu to counter China’s rivalry. However, it must be cautious about over-promising and under-delivering, as only a few people are actually in these new embassies.

Micronesia’s Geopolitical Significance: A Hidden Gem

China and Micronesia’s partnership is not just about strengthening economic ties but also has geopolitical implications. The Pacific region is seen as a new battleground for influence among major powers, including China, the United States, and Australia.

Micronesia’s location and vast economic zones make it a focal point in this global power struggle. China has extended financial assistance and investments to Micronesia for infrastructure projects, aiming to boost economic development and connectivity.

A joint China-Micronesia development fund has facilitated financing for critical projects, aiming to reduce poverty, enhance local industries, and address climate change challenges. Micronesia, a group of thousands of islands in the western Pacific Ocean, is often overlooked due to its small population and remote location, but its strategic position provides a crucial advantage for Pacific nation ambitions.

Climate Change Protection Challenges

Micronesia, a Pacific island nation, is collaborating with China to combat climate change and rising sea levels. The two nations are working on renewable energy projects and coastal protection measures, leveraging China’s expertise in clean energy technology. However, there are concerns about hidden strings attached to China’s investments in Micronesia, potentially compromising the nation’s sovereignty.

Additionally, some Chinese-funded projects have environmental impacts. The deepening relationship with China has also raised concerns among traditional allies, particularly the United States, which has historically provided financial assistance and security guarantees. The burgeoning China-Micronesia partnership has created a delicate balancing act for the Micronesian government, as it aims to maintain its relationships with both superpowers.

The US Influence: The United States Factor

The US is concerned about China’s growing influence in the Pacific region, viewing it as a challenge to its strategic interests. The US government emphasizes the need for Micronesia to maintain balance in international relations. However, the complex situation for Micronesia, which values its historical ties with the US, and the economic benefits of engaging with China, puts it in a challenging position in the changing dynamics of great power competition.

The US Pivot to Micronesia

The United States regards Micronesia as a crucial ally and administered it as a United Nations Trust Territory after WWII. In 1986, the Compact of Free Association granted Micronesia full sovereignty in exchange for defence and financial support, enabling the US to establish military bases and maintain a strong presence in the Pacific.

China’s Growing Ambitions

China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) has significantly expanded its global influence, with investments and development projects in various Pacific nations, including Micronesia, as Beijing seeks to establish a foothold in the region.

Economic Diplomacy vs. Military Presence

China’s approach in Micronesia focuses on economic diplomacy, providing financial aid, infrastructure development, and trade agreements to win the hearts and minds of Micronesian leaders and populations. The US, on the other hand, relies on its military presence to maintain influence in the Pacific, conducting joint exercises and building alliances to counter China’s growing assertiveness.

Challenges and Dilemmas

Micronesia faces a dilemma of great power competition, benefiting from economic development and investment from the US and China. However, it also faces the risk of being drawn into conflicts. Micronesian governments must balance their relationships with these superpowers while safeguarding their sovereignty and interests. Their strategic and economic decisions have significant implications for their future and the Pacific geopolitics.

Challenges and DilemmasChinaChina's Growing AmbitionsClimate Change Protection ChallengesEconomic Diplomacy vs. Military PresenceMicronesiaMicronesia's Geopolitical Significance: A Hidden GemThe US Influence: The United States FactorThe US Pivot to MicronesiaUnited StatesUSUS ChinaUS-China Geopolitical Battle Impacts Micronesia's Future: A Delicate Balancing Act