US Congress Challenges Trump’s Order to Scrap EMALS as Navy Warns of Costly Ford-Class Carrier Redesign in $10 Billion Rebuff

Ford-Class Carrier

US Senate Armed Services Committee Chairman Roger Wicker has firmly rejected President Donald Trump’s proposal to replace electromagnetic aircraft launch systems with traditional steam-powered catapults on future US aircraft carriers, describing the proposed reversal as a “non-starter” and warning that it could impose enormous financial and operational costs on the Navy.

Wicker made the remarks during a Senate confirmation hearing for Acting Navy Secretary Hung Cao, signalling growing congressional resistance to Trump’s effort to reverse one of the most significant technological changes introduced in the US Navy’s latest generation of aircraft carriers.

“Secretary Cao, returning to steam is a non-starter, and everybody needs to understand that,” Wicker told Cao during the hearing.

The confrontation followed questions from Senator Tim Kaine, a Virginia Democrat, about an August presidential memorandum directing the Navy to develop a plan to equip the upcoming USS Doris Miller and other future aircraft carriers with conventional steam catapults and hydraulic weapons elevators instead of the electromagnetic and advanced elevator technologies currently incorporated into the Ford-class design.

Issued on August 13, the memorandum targets aircraft carriers that have not yet been equipped with the Electromagnetic Aircraft Launch System (EMALS) and Advanced Weapons Elevators (AWEs), technologies developed to improve aircraft-launch efficiency, weapons handling and overall carrier operations.

The USS Gerald R. Ford (CVN-78), the lead ship of the Ford class and the world’s largest aircraft carrier, is the first US carrier to incorporate these systems.

Kaine questioned whether abandoning the technology after years of development and investment would make operational or financial sense, particularly given the experience of sailors currently operating the systems.

“Based on what the folks on the flight deck told me, the EMALS system works very, very well,” Kaine said, referring to his recent visit to the USS Gerald R. Ford.

He said he had spoken with flight-deck personnel who had experience operating both traditional steam catapults and the newer electromagnetic launch system.

“I do hope you’ll consider the experience of those who’ve been operating these launchers on the Ford in deciding before you go down a path that will be more expensive and also less capable,” he told Cao.

Cao, who has served as acting Navy secretary since April, pointed to the difficulties associated with developing and integrating the Ford-class technologies. He argued that electromagnetic systems and other technical challenges had contributed to delays in aircraft-carrier construction and warned that the Navy could face a period with only nine operational carriers.

He claimed that the systems were “delaying our carriers by seven years,” highlighting the broader challenges confronting the US Navy’s shipbuilding programme.

Although Cao emphasised the need to accelerate carrier construction and improve industrial capacity, he stopped short of explicitly endorsing or rejecting Trump’s proposed return to steam-powered technology.

The resistance is also emerging within the Republican-controlled Congress.

In an explanatory statement accompanying their fiscal 2027 defence appropriations bill released on Monday, Senate Republican appropriators warned that a major redesign of future aircraft carriers to accommodate steam catapults and hydraulic elevators could create substantial financial and scheduling problems.

The lawmakers cautioned that such a change “would result in many billions of dollars in additional costs and many years in program schedule delays.”

They directed the Navy to submit a comprehensive comparison of the electromagnetic and steam-powered systems, covering sortie-generation rates, aircraft compatibility, elevator performance, manpower requirements, operational readiness and overall combat effectiveness.

The appropriators also warned against implementing major changes to the carrier programme without sufficient technical analysis and congressional oversight.

They specifically cautioned against “such significant programmatic shifts without substantive analysis, justification, and Congressional approval.”

Importantly, the Senate appropriators noted that recent combat experience involving the USS Gerald R. Ford appeared to demonstrate improvements in aircraft sortie rates, operational readiness and combat lethality compared with previous generations of aircraft carriers.

The assessment presents a significant challenge to Trump’s argument that the electromagnetic technology should be abandoned in favour of older mechanical systems.

Wicker has previously expressed support for continuing with EMALS. In August, he said there was “overwhelming support in Congress and in the Pentagon for moving forward with EMALS,” adding that some of the programme’s associated industrial work takes place in Mississippi.

Initial estimates for the engineering and design work required to reintroduce steam-powered catapults have reportedly reached approximately $10 billion. The United States has not manufactured steam catapults for roughly two decades, raising additional questions about whether the industrial capacity and specialised expertise needed to restart production remain readily available.

Earlier Navy assessments also indicated that switching technologies could add at least 18 months to the construction schedules of ships already designed around electromagnetic launch systems.

Trump’s opposition to EMALS is not new. He has repeatedly criticised electromagnetic catapults and advanced weapons elevators, arguing that they are unnecessarily complicated, expensive and difficult to repair.

During remarks aboard the USS George Washington, Trump announced that future aircraft carriers should return to conventional steam-powered catapults and hydraulic elevators.

“I’m putting out an order, I’m going to sign an executive order, when we build aircraft carriers, it’s steam for the catapults, and it’s hydraulic for the elevators. Do you agree? Everybody agrees,” he said.

Trump argued that electromagnetic systems require expensive technical support and specialised engineers whenever problems occur, whereas traditional steam catapults can be repaired using comparatively simple tools and maintenance procedures.

“They’re spending billions of dollars to build stupid electric. And the problem, when it breaks, you have to send up to MIT, get the most brilliant people in the world, fly them out,” Trump said.

“The steam, they said, they can fix it with a hammer and blowtorch. And it works just as well, if not better.”

He also praised the historical performance of steam catapults, which powered generations of American aircraft carriers for approximately half a century.

Trump’s criticism dates back to his first presidency. In 2017, he described electromagnetic catapults as “no good.” During a 2019 visit to the US Navy in Japan, he again criticised the technology, referring to it as “crazy electric” and “very, very complex.”

His latest memorandum seeks to translate those longstanding criticisms into a broader restructuring of the Navy’s future carrier programme.

However, the proposed change would require substantial modifications to ships whose designs, production arrangements and supporting infrastructure have been developed around electromagnetic systems.

Despite the Navy’s commitment to EMALS and advanced weapons elevators, the technology has faced significant reliability challenges since the USS Gerald R. Ford entered service.

The $13 billion carrier was designed around a new generation of systems intended to increase aircraft-launch capacity, improve operational efficiency and reduce the manpower required to operate carrier aviation.

However, early testing revealed repeated failures involving both the Electromagnetic Aircraft Launch System and the Advanced Arresting Gear (AAG), which recovers aircraft after landing.

A 2018 Bloomberg report, citing the annual assessment of the Pentagon’s Office of the Director of Operational Test and Evaluation (DOT&E), reported that EMALS experienced 10 critical failures during 747 aircraft launches in at-sea trials following the carrier’s delivery in 2017.

The Advanced Arresting Gear recorded 10 operational mission failures during 763 aircraft landing attempts over the same period.

According to the report, EMALS experienced a critical failure approximately once every 455 launches, around nine times more frequently than the Navy’s desired reliability rate.

The carrier’s 11 Advanced Weapons Elevators, designed to transport ammunition and other aircraft stores from the ship’s magazines to the flight deck, also encountered repeated technical difficulties.

More recent Pentagon assessments suggest that the reliability challenges have not been fully resolved despite engineering improvements and software upgrades.

A DOT&E report published earlier this year said that the reliability of EMALS had not improved substantially despite hardware and software modifications.

“Despite engineering upgrades to hardware and software, reliability has not appreciably changed from prior years, and reliance on off-ship technical support remains a challenge,” the report stated.

The report added that Naval Air Systems Command (NAVAIR) had delivered a software update and upgraded all catapult position sensor blocks before the USS Gerald R. Ford’s deployment as part of efforts to address reliability problems.

Further improvements remain under development.

The Advanced Arresting Gear has faced similar difficulties.

“Despite some software and hardware improvements in AAG, reliability has not appreciably changed because the FY23 data reflects many short-duration failures that were unreported in the developmental test, as well as system-of-systems degradations, all of which would have prevented landing,” the DOT&E report said.

It also highlighted difficulties in obtaining replacement components and the Navy’s continued dependence on technical assistance from personnel located outside the ship.

“NAVAIR continues to work on short- and long-term improvements to address AAG reliability degraders. However, difficulties such as obtaining replacement parts and the reliance on off-ship technical support remain a challenge,” the report added.

These problems have strengthened arguments among critics who believe the Navy moved too quickly towards complex electromagnetic systems without sufficiently resolving their operational weaknesses.

Nevertheless, supporters of EMALS argue that the technology offers important advantages over steam-powered catapults, including more precise control of launch energy, reduced mechanical stress on aircraft and the ability to accommodate a wider range of aircraft weights.

The electromagnetic system is also intended to support future carrier-based aircraft and unmanned platforms that may require different launch characteristics.

The dispute goes beyond the technical differences between steam and electromagnetic catapults. It reflects a broader disagreement over how the United States should rebuild its declining naval industrial base while maintaining the technological advantages required for future maritime competition.

Trump’s August memorandum called for measures to address what he described as an “atrophied shipbuilding industrial base,” arguing that the construction and repair of American warships had become excessively slow and expensive.

His administration has presented the proposed return to established technologies as part of an effort to simplify shipbuilding, reduce maintenance complexity and restore industrial capacity.

However, critics argue that replacing systems already integrated into the Ford-class design could produce the opposite result by forcing the Navy to restart manufacturing processes, redesign major ship components and retrain specialised personnel.

The USS Doris Miller, the planned fourth Ford-class aircraft carrier, is particularly relevant to the debate because it is among the future ships targeted by Trump’s directive.

For the Navy, the central question is whether the operational advantages of returning to steam would justify the financial and scheduling consequences of changing an established carrier design.

The Senate’s demand for a detailed comparative assessment suggests that Congress is unwilling to accept the presidential directive without stronger technical evidence.

The latest confrontation between Wicker and Cao therefore highlights a growing institutional divide over the future of American aircraft-carrier technology.

While Trump wants the Navy to abandon electromagnetic launch systems in favour of traditional steam technology, senior lawmakers are warning that reversing course could cost billions of dollars, delay ship deliveries and undermine the Navy’s long-term modernisation programme.

Related Posts