Australia’s renewed Sandpapergate controversy has exposed divisions over whether the country’s cricket establishment should finally close the chapter on the 2018 ball-tampering scandal or confront unanswered questions about who knew what and when.
Former Australian Deputy Prime Minister Michael McCormack has called for the controversy to be put behind the sport, arguing that the punishments imposed on former Test captain Steve Smith, David Warner and Cameron Bancroft were sufficient.
“It’s done. Move on,” McCormack told News24’s Kieran Gilbert, pointing to the suspensions handed to the three players following the scandal in Cape Town.
Former Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull, however, has taken a different approach, questioning why Australian batter Usman Khawaja waited years before publicly raising allegations about the incident.
“Why didn’t he speak up at the time?” Turnbull asked after Khawaja’s memoir claimed that the entire touring squad knew about the ball-tampering plan during Australia’s 2018 tour of South Africa.
Their contrasting positions have intensified scrutiny of Cricket Australia’s newly announced independent forum, which aims to address the controversy without reopening the original disciplinary investigation.
Cricket Australia Interim Chair David Boon and Chief Executive Todd Greenberg announced the initiative on Wednesday, describing it as an opportunity to create a “circuit breaker” around the renewed dispute.
Players and support staff who toured South Africa in 2018 will be invited to provide confidential accounts before Christmas, as Australia’s summer cricket season gathers momentum.
However, the proposed process has already raised questions about transparency and accountability.
Greenberg has ruled out additional sanctions and said the forum would not seek to “re-prosecute” the original investigation. Speaking at a press conference in Hobart, he also acknowledged that the organization was not pursuing a definitive account of every detail.
“Looking for the perfect truth doesn’t exist, so we’re not chasing it,” he said.
That position contrasts with the expectations of former players and sections of the public seeking a clearer explanation of the events that damaged Australian cricket’s international reputation.
Warner, speaking to Fox Sports after the announcement, said: “What the public want is the truth.”
Khawaja also welcomed the forum but questioned whether a confidential process, with Cricket Australia retaining control over the publication of findings, could deliver meaningful closure.
“I could go in there and say something, but then the board can decide that they’re not going to release that. I just feel like then we just go in a circle,” he said.
“We want to move on. The question is: will this allow us to move on?”
Khawaja’s memoir has added another dimension to the controversy, alleging that sandpaper was used during the second Test against South Africa in Port Elizabeth, the match before the Cape Town incident became public.
Warner has supported Khawaja’s account, while former Australian batting coach Graeme Hick has said he knew nothing about discussions surrounding ball tampering in either Test.
Khawaja has also faced questions about whether current Test captain Pat Cummins knew about the plan. Cummins responded emphatically on November 13, rejecting any suggestion that he knew sandpaper had been taken onto the field.
He described the allegation as “100% not true.”
The controversy has also drawn responses from Australian political leaders, many of whom appear reluctant to become directly involved.
Sports Minister Anika Wells said Cummins had addressed the issue extensively and that Cricket Australia should handle the matter.
“Right now there is a summer of cricket to look forward to,” she said.
Coalition sports spokeswoman Angie Bell similarly declined to comment on the specific allegations, saying the matter was ultimately for Cricket Australia to consider.
Turnbull, who described the original scandal in 2018 as a “terrible disgrace,” has argued that if Smith accepted responsibility for individuals who remained silent, those people should reflect on their own actions.
His intervention has shifted attention beyond the three players who received formal punishments, raising questions about whether responsibility for the episode extended further within the team.
Smith, Warner and Bancroft were sanctioned, but if other players or officials knew about the plan, the circumstances surrounding the original investigation warrant closer examination.
The controversy also raises questions about Cricket Australia’s institutional responsibility.
An independent cultural review conducted after the scandal found that a “win at all costs” mentality had developed within the men’s team. Cricket Australia subsequently said it had implemented 36 of the review’s 42 recommendations.
Greenberg has acknowledged that the episode caused considerable pain and that Cricket Australia itself contributed to the culture in which the incident occurred.
That institutional history makes the credibility of the new forum particularly important.
Cricket Australia helped oversee the culture that preceded the scandal, conducted the original investigation and will now determine what information from the latest process becomes public.
Confidential discussions may encourage former players and officials to speak more openly. But without meaningful disclosure, the forum risks producing another round of competing accounts rather than a lasting resolution.
Eight years after Sandpapergate, Australian cricket faces a difficult choice: move on from a scandal whose full circumstances remain contested, or establish enough transparency to explain why the incident happened, who was responsible and whether the original response told the complete story.