Four French presidential hopefuls launched a series of attacks against far-right leader Marine Le Pen during a televised debate on Monday, challenging her economic proposals, public housing policies and plans to restrict the political activities of nonprofit organizations receiving public funding.
The debate, focused primarily on the rising cost of living and economic pressures facing ordinary households, brought together candidates from across France’s political spectrum. Voters struggling to make ends meet questioned the politicians about their proposed solutions, placing Le Pen, who holds a commanding lead in opinion polls, under sustained pressure from her rivals.
The participants included far-left leader Jean-Luc Mélenchon, conservative leader Bruno Retailleau, centrist Gabriel Attal and center-left European Parliament member Raphaël Glucksmann. Their exchanges highlighted growing political divisions over public spending, taxation, social welfare and the role of civil society ahead of the next presidential election.
One of the sharpest confrontations came when Retailleau challenged Le Pen’s economic programme, particularly her pledge to generate €140 billion in savings by 2032.
“Your budget trajectory is a joke, it doesn’t add up,” Retailleau told Le Pen, questioning the financial credibility of her proposals.
The criticism placed the far-right leader on the defensive over how she intends to finance her commitments while addressing the economic concerns of French households.
However, the most heated exchange of the evening concerned Le Pen’s proposal to impose restrictions on charities and nonprofit organizations that receive public funding.
Le Pen said such organizations should be required to refrain from engaging in political activities, arguing that publicly funded charities should not use taxpayer money to advance political positions.
Her proposal immediately drew criticism from Attal, who compared her approach to that of Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán and other leaders accused of restricting independent organizations and dissenting voices.
“Your model is the same as that of your friends, Mr. Orbán and others, which is ultimately to shut up and stop those who do not think like you,” Attal said.
The exchange intensified when Le Pen indicated that she would provide a list of charities she considered excessively political.
“You’ve got a list,” Mélenchon responded, suggesting that the proposal could lead to the targeting of organizations critical of her political movement.
The confrontation exposed a broader disagreement over the independence of civil society organizations, the use of public money and the limits of government intervention in nonprofit activities.
Throughout the debate, Le Pen appeared cautious, seeking to avoid prolonged confrontations with her opponents while maintaining her position as the leading candidate in opinion polls. Her most direct attacks were directed at Attal, the leader of President Emmanuel Macron’s Renaissance party, who served briefly as prime minister in 2024.
Le Pen accused Attal of bearing responsibility for France’s deteriorating public finances during the Macron administration.
“I don’t have any lessons to learn from someone who spent 10 years creating the biggest debt in the history of this country,” she said.
The comment reflected Le Pen’s strategy of linking her political opponents to the economic record of Macron’s government, particularly France’s rising public debt and concerns about government spending.
Despite the heated exchanges, Le Pen and Mélenchon largely avoided directly confronting each other. Mélenchon, who is polling in second place and could potentially face Le Pen in a presidential runoff, instead used the debate to promote his own economic agenda.
One of his most striking proposals was to impose a 100 percent inheritance tax on fortunes exceeding €12 million.
“After 12 million, we take everything,” Mélenchon declared, presenting the measure as part of his broader campaign for greater economic redistribution and a reduction in inherited wealth.
The proposal highlighted the sharp ideological differences between the candidates, particularly over taxation, wealth distribution and the future of France’s economic model.
The debate also included lighter moments. Le Pen and Mélenchon briefly found common ground when both complained that the television studio was too cold. Retailleau also appeared amused when Mélenchon argued that France’s pension system was not facing a crisis.
The absence of another prominent presidential hopeful, Edouard Philippe, was also notable. The center-right politician and mayor of Le Havre did not participate because of a scheduling conflict involving a municipal council meeting, according to his team.
Philippe was previously considered one of the strongest potential challengers to Le Pen in a presidential runoff. However, his standing in opinion polls has weakened, complicating his prospects in an increasingly competitive political landscape.
The televised confrontation provided an early indication of how France’s presidential contest could develop, with the cost of living, public finances, taxation and the independence of civil society emerging as central political battlegrounds.
For Le Pen, the challenge will be to translate her polling advantage into broader credibility on economic policy while responding to accusations that her proposed restrictions on nonprofit organizations could undermine democratic freedoms.
Her opponents, meanwhile, sought to demonstrate that her economic promises and political programme deserve closer scrutiny, signalling that the campaign against the far right is likely to focus as much on the practical consequences of its policies as on its political ideology.