The Australian government has scrapped a $14 million programme designed to recruit 1,000 digital trainees into the public service after government agencies hired just 73 people, raising questions about the Albanese government’s ability to translate workforce development commitments into practical outcomes.
The programme, announced at the Albanese government’s September 2022 Jobs and Skills Summit, was intended to create 1,000 digital traineeships over four years. It aimed to strengthen digital capabilities across the Australian Public Service (APS) while opening employment opportunities for groups traditionally underrepresented in the workforce, including women, First Nations people, older Australians and veterans transitioning to civilian life.
However, newly released documents obtained under freedom of information (FOI) laws show that Public Service Minister Katy Gallagher decided to terminate the initiative in October 2025 after receiving advice that participation from government agencies remained extremely low despite repeated efforts to redesign and promote the programme.
The documents reveal a significant gap between the government’s original ambition and its implementation. Although the programme attracted a strong pool of applicants and received support from senior public servants and politicians, agencies failed to create enough positions to accommodate candidates.
A signed ministerial brief dated October 27, 2025, confirmed the decision to close the programme, citing limited returns from the investment and concerns that further changes might not produce meaningful improvements.
The Australian Public Service Commission (APSC), in advice provided to Gallagher in September 2025, acknowledged that the programme had a strong justification but was struggling to achieve its objectives.
According to the commission, 71 per cent of government agencies reported shortages of digital skills. Meanwhile, spending on external digital labour across the public sector had reached approximately AU$1.92 billion, equivalent to the employment cost of around 6,000 full-time workers.
Despite these shortages, fewer than 60 candidates had secured placements when the commission prepared its September assessment. The figure was subsequently revised to 73 during Senate Estimates hearings in May 2026.
The low recruitment numbers exposed a major implementation problem: agencies were unable or unwilling to translate their demand for digital expertise into entry-level employment opportunities.
The APSC identified several structural weaknesses that prevented the programme from gaining momentum.
One of the central problems was that agencies were not expanding their entry-level recruitment numbers sufficiently to create demand for digital trainees. Consequently, many candidates who had successfully passed the selection process remained on merit lists without receiving employment offers.
The commission also found that government departments were reluctant to invest in developing inexperienced workers because of immediate operational pressures.
“Capability building is seen as too time and resource intensive from the ground up: Agencies are feeling immediate delivery pressures, and reluctant to invest in longer-term development,” the APSC said in its assessment.
Another concern was that the programme was not sufficiently aligned with the specific digital skills required by individual agencies.
Government departments wanted recruitment pathways that addressed their immediate technical requirements rather than a broader traineeship model that required substantial training and development.
The commission also found that agencies considered the programme relatively expensive compared with other entry-level recruitment options.
Under the existing structure, employing a digital trainee cost approximately AU$8,800. This compared with AU$5,000 for a graduate who had completed a university qualification within the previous five years and AU$6,000 for a cadet undertaking a digital degree after completing at least 12 months of study.
The difference in recruitment costs further weakened the programme’s appeal among agencies already facing budgetary and staffing pressures.
In response to the problems, the APSC presented several options for restructuring the initiative. These included renaming it “Digital Skills Uplift” and reducing its scale to approximately 50 placements annually.
However, Gallagher was not convinced that another redesign would resolve the underlying problems.
According to the ministerial brief signed on October 27, the minister had indicated in September that she wanted to terminate the programme because of its limited returns and the continuing risk that restructuring would fail to deliver the expected improvements.
The brief stated that Gallagher supported closure “on the basis of low returns for the efforts so far and the residual high risk that the redesign may still not deliver desired levels of improvements.”
The commission also warned that cancelling the programme could generate criticism from candidates who had successfully entered the merit pool but had not secured placements. It could also disappoint a small number of agencies that had obtained value from employing digital trainees.
The document cautioned that closure “may appear as a reduction in the number of entry level pathways”, particularly to candidates awaiting employment opportunities.
Nevertheless, the government proceeded with the decision.
The May 2026 federal budget subsequently confirmed the programme’s termination, revealing savings of AU$14 million over four years beginning in 2026–27. The cancellation will also generate ongoing savings of approximately AU$3.5 million annually thereafter.
The decision has attracted criticism from the opposition, which argues that the programme’s failure reflects broader weaknesses in the government’s approach to public-sector workforce development.
Acting shadow public service minister Jane Hume described the initiative as an “absolute failure” at a time when the Australian government should have been strengthening its digital capabilities.
She criticised the Albanese government’s major policy consultations, including the 2022 Jobs and Skills Summit and the 2025 Economic Reform Roundtable, arguing that they had failed to deliver tangible benefits.
“Australians know Labor’s talkfests, like the 2022 Jobs and Skills Summit and the 2025 Economic Reform Roundtable, have not achieved anything for them,” Hume said.
The government has faced questions about why agencies failed to recruit more trainees despite widespread acknowledgement of digital skills shortages and the substantial cost of relying on external contractors.
During Senate Estimates hearings in May 2026, APSC Deputy Commissioner Subho Banerjee acknowledged the disappointing outcome but said agencies had generally supported the idea of creating more flexible pathways for recruiting entry-level digital professionals.
Banerjee said agencies were “very supportive of thinking about more flexible ways of getting more entry level digital talent”, although implementing such an approach had proved difficult.
He also pointed to competition for entry-level workers in the digital sector, arguing that the government was competing with other potential employers for people entering digital professions.
However, the challenge of competing with private-sector employers was not identified in the ministerial closure brief as one of the principal reasons for terminating the initiative.
Banerjee said the commission was disappointed with the outcome, particularly because it had repeatedly engaged senior officials across government departments to encourage participation.
“We’ve had repeat conversations at senior levels with secretaries, with deputies, with chief information officers, with chief people officers and with COOs over the period of the program,” he said.
He acknowledged that placements had been slow during the programme’s initial stages and that officials had hoped the situation would improve, particularly through participation from larger government agencies.
“Placements were slow in the initial period,” Banerjee said, adding that there had been indications that the programme could be turned around.
“That has not proven to be the case.”
Gallagher had previously defended the decision by pointing to the programme’s failure to generate permanent employment opportunities for participants.
“The advice to me is that it hasn’t been as effective [as hoped] … This program wasn’t resulting, I think, in permanent placements in agencies,” she said.
The cancellation raises broader questions about Australia’s approach to building digital expertise within government, particularly as public-sector agencies increasingly depend on technology, cybersecurity, data management and digital infrastructure.
The programme was initially presented as a way to reduce skills shortages, develop a domestic talent pipeline and expand access to public-sector employment for people facing barriers to traditional recruitment pathways.
Its failure to reach even one-tenth of its 1,000-person target highlights the difficulties of implementing cross-government recruitment initiatives when individual agencies retain control over staffing decisions and prioritise immediate operational requirements.
The APSC’s assessment also exposed a contradiction in the government’s workforce strategy: agencies collectively reported substantial digital skills shortages and spent billions of dollars on external expertise, yet they did not create enough entry-level positions to support a relatively small traineeship programme.
Ultimately, the decision to abandon the initiative represents a retreat from one of the workforce development commitments made at the 2022 Jobs and Skills Summit.
While the government will save millions of dollars by ending the programme, the underlying challenge of addressing digital skills shortages across the Australian Public Service remains unresolved.